Review as an ensemble.
No review bot seat. Each teammate reviews with their own Claude Code or Codex, on their own machine. Every pull request gets the same review on every push, checked against its ticket. GitHub is the source of truth.
On dana’s Open PRs: Reviewed by @sam
Runs fully locally, with no added service.
Between a review bot and a prompt.
The process of a review bot, on the plans your team already has, with the ticket and your docs in hand.
A review bot
A seat for each person, paid for on top of the AI plans you already have.
Your agent alone
No extra cost, but a different review each time, from a prompt someone wrote. It stays on one machine, and two people can do the same one.
Ensemble
The same review on every push, checked against the ticket’s acceptance criteria and description, your docs and the earlier threads. Posted to GitHub once, for the whole team.
No one in charge. GitHub keeps the score.
The review is decentralised. Each Ensemble reads what the others left on the pull request, decides for itself, and writes back as its own person. If a teammate’s laptop is closed, yours carries on.
- You, with Claude + Codex: steps aside.
- Sam, with Claude Code: reviewed · 2 comments.
- Dana, with Codex: is reviewing with Codex.
- Priya, with Claude Code: steps aside.
- Leo, with Codex: steps aside.
Read
Read the status lines
Sam’s Ensemble reads the lines on the commit. Nobody holds
ensemble/review-claude, so the commit is free for Claude.Claim
“sam is reviewing with Claude”
Posted, then read again. If two teammates claim at once, the earlier line wins and the other stands down.
Review
Claude Code reviews, on Sam’s machine
With Sam’s own sign-in. The line is posted again every 8 minutes while it runs.
Post
The review goes to GitHub
As Sam’s review, marked as written by Ensemble.
Done
“sam reviewed · 2 comments”
Every other Ensemble on the team skips this commit for Claude. Dana’s Codex review carries on.
Claims
On the commita status line any teammate’s Ensemble can read.
One review per model, per commit.
Before an automatic review starts, your Ensemble claims the pull request’s latest commit with a status line. A teammate’s Ensemble reads it and skips that commit.
There is one line for each model: ensemble/review-claude and ensemble/review-codex. A teammate on Claude does not stop yours reviewing the same commit with Codex.
Reviewing
“sam is reviewing with Claude”
Posted again every 8 minutes while the review runs. Not renewed for 25 minutes, it no longer holds the commit.
Reviewed
“sam reviewed · 2 comments”
The commit is done for Claude. A review kept in Ensemble puts nothing on GitHub, so it holds nothing.
Cleared
“Cleared by sam: review didn’t finish · free to claim”
The review stopped or was skipped. Any Ensemble can review the commit now.
- Claims are per commit. A new push starts again.
- Only automatic reviews claim. A review you start yourself never waits. When you post it, it writes the same “reviewed” line.
- Always on, with no setting. Automatic review is off until you switch it on.
- No write access to the repository? The review runs without a line.
Claude + Codex
The defaultwhen both are signed in.
Two reviews, blind. One result.
Claude and Codex review at the same time, and neither sees the other. At the end their findings are merged into one review: a point both raised shows once, at the higher severity.
If one fails, the other’s findings are still the review. If a teammate already has Claude on the commit, your automatic review runs Codex alone.
Every comment thread gets a judgement.
A later review reads the threads already on the pull request. The newest judgement wins, whoever’s Ensemble made it, and the thread says whose it is.
Its own findings
Each one is followed up: addressed, partly addressed, not addressed or no longer applies. It never assumes “addressed”. A point still open is raised again, linked to the first.
Everyone else’s
A teammate’s, a person’s or another review bot’s comment gets two answers: does the point hold up, and is it addressed. Resolved threads too.
Check threads
With automatic review on, new comments on the same commit start a light pass that judges only the threads that changed, not a full review.
Replies
When the author answers one of your Ensemble’s findings, the replies pass judges the answer by itself. Accepted: the finding is settled for good. Disputed: one pushback per thread, ever, on automatic runs that post.
In place of a review bot. And it fixes.
Switch on automatic review for a workspace and each new pull request is reviewed. The review is posted to GitHub: by default on your pull requests and the ones you review, or on every one. It approves or asks for changes when your rules allow, or only comments. Each of these is a setting.
AI Fix fixes the findings, threads and CI failures you pick, in a sandbox on your machine, and runs your tests. Push when done pushes it to your own pull request when every item is fixed.
Auto fix, off until you switch it on, fixes what an automatic review or CI review found on your own pull requests. Push automatically is a second switch, also off.
You can’t approve your own pull request.
GitHub doesn’t allow it, and Ensemble follows GitHub. On your own pull request, your review is a comment, and it never holds the commit.
A teammate’s Ensemble picks it up first, follows up on the points yours raised, and can approve. “Where this PR stands” shows the verdict GitHub holds for each reviewer.
Latest commit 8a8ec14
1c4bd65Approve8a8ec14CommentRefundPolicy.allows() never reads paid_at.policy.py.One review, however many reviewers.
A review a teammate’s Ensemble posted joins yours on the AI Review tab. Each finding says who raised it. A closed one says why.
A teammate’s point still open? Post reminder raises it again under your name, with a link to theirs. Their comment is never edited.
Who has it now.
Waiting on others lists your pull requests that are with someone else, and for how many working hours. Past your review target, it says so. Nudge asks them again, on GitHub.
What it never does
- Count as CI. Ensemble’s lines are left out of every check count and merge verdict. Don’t make them required checks.
- Hold a commit for good. Ensemble clears a line its own review left behind, and a teammate’s that went stale. The AI Review tab has a Clear button too.
- Post without asking. A review goes to GitHub when you press Post or Review and post, or from automatic review, once you switch it on.
- Touch a teammate’s thread. It never edits their comment or resolves their thread. A reminder is a new comment of yours.
- Show what was kept. A review kept in Ensemble never reaches GitHub, so no teammate sees it.
Free for up to 3 people. A licence above that.
Ensemble is free for individuals, and for organisations where no more than 3 people use it. A bigger team needs a licence.
npx ensemble-review- Each person runs
npx ensemble-reviewon their own machine. - Each person signs in to GitHub with gh, and to Claude Code, Codex or both.
- Nothing is sent to us. We run no server for the app.
- More than 3 people? Ask through the contact form.